The Saturday Slash

Don't be afraid to ask for help with the most critical first step of your writing journey - the query.

I’ve been blogging since 2011 and have critiqued over 200 queries here on the blog using my Hatchet of Death. This is how I edit myself, it is how I edit others. If you think you want to play with me and my hatchet, shoot me an email.

If the Saturday Slash has been helpful to you in the past, or if you’d like for me to take a look at your query please consider making a donation, if you are able.

If you’re ready to take the next step, I also offer editing services.

My thoughts are in blue, words to delete are in red, suggested rephrasing is in orange.

Computer scientist Bex Pascoe has scored her dream job—a tenure-track position at Hamilton University. Her office may overlook the garbage bins, but the name on the door is hers. This sentence construction is a little bit awkward. There's nothing quite wrong with it, but I'd rephrase it slightly for flow. The problem is that her grad school sweetheart, Jake, has a job two thousand miles away. Bex grew up watching her mother depend on a man for money. Giving up her own paycheck to follow Jake is unthinkable. They’ve already spent two years apart, and Bex gives them one more hiring season to find jobs in the same place. This feels a little bit more like a synopsis, and it's not really tying together how watching her mother depend on a man affects her today. It's just a sentence kind of sitting there with the others.

When Hamilton advertises a position in Jake’s specialty, Bex enlists two members of the search committee: the inconveniently attractive Jayden and his polished ex-girlfriend, Maddie. With their help, she counts votes and calls in favors. Convinced that a major solo publication would clinch Jake’s interview, Bex makes one more adjustment. She persuades the editor of their breakthrough article to take her name off it. Jake prides himself on making his own name, but an office on the Quad is a hell of a cure for moral outrage. This is definitely wandering into synopsis territory rather than reading like a query. I don't know how Jayden and Maddie factor into this story, what the point of them is, or how they factor into the plot.

Jake makes the shortlist; then his name disappears overnight. Apparently, counting the votes is not the same as understanding how Hamilton works. The job goes to the dean’s niece. Their last hiring season is over. Her colleagues have instructions for everything down to the height of her heels. When she’s up for tenure in six years, it’ll be Bex’s turn to find out what her colleagues’ votes are worth. She can keep reshaping her life around Hamilton and risk losing Jake for good—or give up the salary and prestige she has fought for to start over with him. Again, not really sure that there's a great setup here. It doesn't sound like a very hard decision. She just found out that the place she works at is rife with corruption, so why would she want to stay there?

THE FALL SEMESTER is a 91,000-word upmarket campus novel about a relationship caught in the machinery of a tenure-track search. It alternates between Bex’s first semester on the faculty and the graduate-school years, in which she and Jake fell in love. It will appeal to readers who enjoyed the academic satire of Elaine Hsieh Chou’s DISORIENTATION and the tangled loyalties of Caroline O’Donoghue’s THE RACHEL INCIDENT.

My debut novel draws on my marriage to another academic and our repeated efforts to solve the two-body problem: finding academic jobs in the same place. I am a professor of political science at the University of Toronto. I have published op-eds in The Guardian and the Toronto Star.

I can see that there could be something here, but 91k words is a lot for something that doesn't feel like it has much kick to it. If the only thing at stake is choosing between a job in a controlling atmosphere and a romantic relationship, I just don't feel like there's much at stake here. We also don't have any understanding of the relationship based on this query. Jake might totally suck. This relationship might not be good for Bex, either. Right now this query is lacking urgency. If you can find a way to make the struggle a little more clear, and the plot more urgent that would help. But right now this is not reading as a particularly intersting read.

The Saturday Slash

Don't be afraid to ask for help with the most critical first step of your writing journey - the query.

I’ve been blogging since 2011 and have critiqued over 200 queries here on the blog using my Hatchet of Death. This is how I edit myself, it is how I edit others. If you think you want to play with me and my hatchet, shoot me an email.

If the Saturday Slash has been helpful to you in the past, or if you’d like for me to take a look at your query please consider making a donation, if you are able.

If you’re ready to take the next step, I also offer editing services.

My thoughts are in blue, words to delete are in red, suggested rephrasing is in orange.

THE POWER OF FIRE is a first person POV, 85,000-word standalone middle grade fantasy novel with series potential. It tells the story of a young girl who has ancient powers and a destiny with an ancestral society on another planet, blending the dragon within in Dragonborn with the journey of feeling unwanted to finding belonging in Nevermoor. You may want to clarify the author(s) of your comp titles. Fantasy isn't really my arena so I realize these may be highly recongizable titles, but I still recomemend stating the author.

Brenda is a thirteen year old girl who has the power to see dragons when she looks into fire. But what does that mean? If I stare long enough into fire I can see things too. Do they talk to her? What's the importance of this? Her whole life, she has lived with her absent father, like he's distracted? or truly not present? never knowing of her powers until the morning of her birthday. When Brenda joins the academy of her ancestors and learns what it means to belong, she uncovers the planet’s dark past and realizes she may be the only one who can defeat the tyranny that has befallen it. That's a pretty big leap from she gets her powers, her father is absent, and now she's in an ancestral academy on another planet. Also, right now the plot is very vague "chosen one" trope, without really illustrating what makes this story different from every other Chosen one narrative.

Her journey at the academy takes an unexpected turn when she becomes trapped in helping to train a man-eating dragon, and she begins to realize the truth of the darkness overshadowing the academy’s light. Again, very vague. What is this darkness? What is the threat?

As she learns to understand her place in the society, a terrible truth emerges: the most powerful Dragon Lord in history has returned with a vow to destroy the academy and complete his conquest to establish total domination of the planet. Right now this is giving a lot of Harry Potter reboot vibes.

When Brenda’s true destiny is revealed, and the walls of darkness close in around the dreamy brilliance of the academy, she must face the weight of her power while knowing that among her new friends and family, she may be the only one who can save them. What is her true destiny, and why is she the only one that can save them? What is the weight of her power? What is her power, anyway?

But this is not only a story of knowing one’s power. It is a journey into the meaning of nobility, purpose, and inner strength, while subsequently guiding the reader into a true understanding of the deep, unmistakable power of love. As I said earlier, this is all very generic at the moment. The Harry Potter vibe is strong - orphaned(ish) child, chosen one, the big bad one guy is coming back and the MC is the only person who can stop them. You need to get into the specficis about what it is that makes this book different from every other book that follows that trope. What is her power? How does she use it? Find the ways that this book is not like others and capitalize on that in your query rather than walking an agent through a plot they already know and have seen often.

The Saturday Slash

Don't be afraid to ask for help with the most critical first step of your writing journey - the query.

I’ve been blogging since 2011 and have critiqued over 200 queries here on the blog using my Hatchet of Death. This is how I edit myself, it is how I edit others. If you think you want to play with me and my hatchet, shoot me an email.

If the Saturday Slash has been helpful to you in the past, or if you’d like for me to take a look at your query please consider making a donation, if you are able.

If you’re ready to take the next step, I also offer editing services.

My thoughts are in blue, words to delete are in red, suggested rephrasing is in orange.

BLOODFIELDER is an adult dystopian romance with series potential complete at 95,000 words, where to survive a yearly sports tournament in which the losing players - and their fans - are killed, a disabled hacker must put her fate in the hands of a mysterious star athlete, who happens to be the very man she must defeat to stay alive. It will appeal to readers who enjoyed the high stakes setup of Dani Francis’ Silver Elite, the rivals-to-lovers romance of Rachel Reid’s Heated Rivalry, and the fusion of competitive sports and speculative world building in Sophie Kim’s The Winged Game. So this definitely sounds interesting, but the hook is a little long-winded. I definitley need to know how a disabled hacker is entered into a sports tournament.

Felicia knows that at any time, The New Earth Empire may fall. The only livable surface on the planet, the Empire’s artificial island has continued to crumble at alarming rates as its dangerously dense population only continues to reach new heights. To prevent a sudden mass death, an annual televised sports tournament is held where the losing athletes - and their fans - are killed. No one knows which sports will be played each year; only that they are deadly, dangerous, and nearly impossible to win. How are the participants chosen? And I'm curious why people would participate as "fans" if they could die as a result. Is this forced interaction? What does the winner get that would make them enter this in the first place?

Yet, Felicia has never truly cared. As a disabled hacker working for the Empire’s government, she’s cheated death multiple times before by changing her registered fandom, and she continues to illegally make a living providing the same service to others. So I initially read this quite wrong - not OnlyFans, but certainly something where she has a fandom of her own, not that she is registered as a fan of an athlete that has lost in the past, could use some clarity. But when she is finally caught for her crimes, she is granted a choice: participate in the games - alongside a ragtag team of fellow criminals, whose pitiful athletic abilities combined can barely survive a warm-up - or face certain execution. Again, the question of how the participants are chosen comes up for me. Is it just criminals? Earlier you commented that no one knows what sport will be played year to year, but why does tht matter if the people going into it aren't athletic anyway?

As an orphan and sole caretaker to her younger brother, she is determined to do whatever it takes to come out of the competition alive and back to him, even if it means forming an alliance with the one person she shouldn’t: Theo Scarling, the very man responsible for her arrest.

Alluring, mysterious, and the only person to survive the tournament more than once, Theo is New Earth’s golden athlete- and Felicia’s greatest enemy. So when he unexpectedly offers to secretly train her team in exchange for a strange favor: when the time comes, Felicia must use her hacking skills to save someone of Theo's choosing, she begrudgingly accepts, knowing that she might not live to see the day he uses it. Yet, as their alliance progresses, undeniable sparks begin to fly between the two, and Felicia soon discovers that falling for the one person who could save her could be just as dangerous as facing him on the field.

As she begins to work with (and compete against) Theo, Felicia begins to see the cracks in the Empire’s carefully constructed narrative, challenging everything she thought she knew about the tournament, the Empire, and even herself. The deeper she digs, the more she suspects that something far darker, and far more sinister, lurks beneath the games. Now, to make it home to her brother, she’ll have to survive the tournament long enough to uncover the truth, all while deciding whether exposing it is worth sacrificing everything she’s fighting for. Because when her life- and her heart- are on the line, Felicia has no choice but to play to win.

Overall this definitely sounds interesting, but I am confused about the setup itself. Same questions as before - why would anyone enter? What's the payoff? What about being a fan? Do you HAVE to participate? And honestly, idk how there could be something more sinister at work than what is blatantly in play here. You're already quite wordy for a query, so this needs to be trimmed down, particularly the last two paragraphs. Your biggest challenge is going to be how to make it clear that this isn't The Hunger Games or Squid Games all over again. The fact that your MC is disabled is probably the biggest distinction, so I would rework this query to show how her own abilities are going to be useful in the field of play, not just an athletic man shows her how to be more athletic.